— Advertisement —

Watch: New Transportation Committee gets intro from SDOT, CM Kettle puts foot in mouth

Wide image of the Transportation Committee from the Seattle Channel video feed.
Watch below or on Seattle Channel.

Seattle’s new City Council held its first Transportation Committee meeting Tuesday, and every member in attendance was a new Councilmember. The only returning Transportation Committee member is Dan Strauss (D6), but he was excused Tuesday because he was in Olympia on city business. Chair Rob Saka (D1), vice-chair Joy Hollingsworth (D3), and members Bob Kettle(D7) and Tanya Woo (interim citywide) were there to hear an introduction to SDOT’s work from SDOT Director Greg Spotts.

The meeting was an opportunity to get a sense of the committee’s early dynamics. Only Saka and Kettle spoke at any length from the dais about their transportation opinions. Councilmember Woo asked questions about community outreach and Sound Transit station siting, but did not pontificate. CM Kettle’s bike lane misinformation ended up being the most notable takeaway from the committee’s first meeting, unfortunately. More on that below.

Saka opened reiterating some things he told Seattle Bike Blog recently, namely that he has “a heavy focus” on bridges and streets. “Representing District 1, which includes West Seattle, one of my goals is to make sure no other community in Seattle experiences what we experienced with a protracted closure of a critical bridge,” he said. “I also want to focus on safety and comfort of pedestrians and making real tangible progress on our Vision Zero goals in part through a once-in-a-generation investment in new sidewalk infrastructure.”

— Advertisement —

Before turning the mic over to Director Spotts, Saka also acknowledged the $1.2–$1.7 billion elephant in the room. “I look forward to a spirited discussion about the size and direction of the upcoming transportation levy with you all and members of the public.”

You can watch the full meeting via Seattle Channel and download SDOT’s slides (PDF). The presentation starts at 13:30, and they paused at various points in the presentation to take questions from the Council around the 29:20, 50:15, and 1:106:00 marks.

As Chair, CM Saka set up the meeting as a chance for the very fresh committee to get an overview of SDOT’s work as well as the kinds of duties the committee will be expected to complete. They also discussed the resources available at SDOT to help committee members if they have questions about various aspects of the sprawling, high-budget department.

CM Kettle, on the other hand, made a bit of a rough entrance. He reminded me of many community council meetings I have attended in my years of community reporting, which too often have one or two members who speak at length about topics they are not experts about rather than ask questions of the experts in attendance. This is mostly tolerated at the community council level, but the standard is higher on City Council.

Some of the things CM Kettle said were just sort of head-scratchers, like when he cautioned that while he does support some safety projects, “There are other streets like I-5 where we should not be doing anything.” I-5 is a state facility and not under the purview of SDOT or the City Council Transportation Committee. He also spoke highly of Mercer Street’s so-called “Intelligent Transportation System,” which has been much maligned for the ways it prioritizes car traffic over walking and biking safety and crossing times while also failing consistently at keeping bike lanes and crosswalks clear of stopped car traffic. I’m also not sure I’ve ever heard a car driver have anything nice to say about the street. CM Kettle said he encourages SDOT to “try to leverage those technologies to improve service” on congested streets. I doubt many regular users of Mercer Street, regardless of mode, are going to agree with his take here.

He also referred to the Magnolia Bridge as “queen of all bridges,” which is a phrase I have not heard before. The Magnolia Bridge was built back when it crossed over water, but the area under it has since been filled in and is part of the port. It is a freeway-style bridge connecting to a low-density part of the city, and it’s miserable to use if you’re outside a car. She’s not my queen, anyway.

Screenshot of a Seattle Bike Blog twitter post with a historic photo of the Magnolia Bridge crossing water.

But the part where he really put his foot in his mouth was when he decided to go on a rant about how bike lanes are “becoming a public safety concern.”

“One thing I’ve learned is they’re becoming a public safety concern,” he said to a panel of transportation and vision zero professionals. “It goes to pedestrian safety primarily. Downtown, Belltown, they go fast. If you have somebody my size and that fast, that’s a lot…it’s physics. If you have an elderly person who’s loving in a condo or apartment building in downtown, Belltown, that becomes a big problem. And that’s something that’s growing.”

There is no evidence that I’m aware of that pedestrian safety issues around bike lanes is, as the councilmember stated as fact, growing. The city is seeing a very disturbing trend in pedestrian deaths and injuries, and on his first day on the job Director Spotts (the guy giving the presentation to the committee), tasked SDOT with conducting a study to find out why. It’s available online, but to roughly summarize: Deaths are happening on wide streets that prioritize moving cars above the safety of people walking. Because as for “physics,” well, a car weighs a lot more than a person on a bicycle. Here are some charts from the report:

Two pie charts. The first shows that 80% of pedestrian deaths were on road with two or more lanes in the same direction. The second shows that 80% of bicycle rider deaths were on roads without bike lanes.

Councilmember Kettle kept digging deeper, saying in a confusing word soup that the Westlake bikeway is also a “growing issue.”

“And tied to this too with the bike lanes, again, if you’re a pedestrian and you’re trying to get to the Starbucks in the AGC building, and you have those protected lanes, and again, with these mobility solutions with these scooters and the like, they go fast. And this pedestrian issue in terms of trying to cross the bike lane to get from one side of Westlake to the other side, to the businesses whether it’s start with Starbucks at AGC or go up to China Harbor. That is a growing issue from a public safety, pedestrian safety as it ties into your slide pieces.”

Comparing two nearby images from google Street View. One shows a four-lane roadway full of traffic with no crosswalks, and the other shows a two-way bike lane with raised crosswalks. Text: Which one is more dangerous to cross?

Where to begin? For people crossing “from one side of Westlake to the other side,” the four lanes of fast traffic with few safe crosswalks are much more dangerous than the bike lane. The main sidewalk there is to the east of the bikeway, so sidewalk users do not need to cross the bikeway to get to businesses. People who park in the public parking lot do need to cross the bikeway, but this was a design decision made to minimize the conflict points between people driving and people biking. Since opening nearly 8 years ago, the Westlake bikeway has become one of the city’s most popular and successful bike routes.

The Vision Zero report shows that no point near the Westlake bikeway cracks the top 20 most dangerous intersections for pedestrians in CM Kettle’s District 7. You what street appears multiple times? Mercer Street.

Map of the 20 most dangerous intersections for pedestrians in each council district. There are no dots on Westlake, but there are dots on Mercer Street.

I know I’m coming off harsh here, but listening to him say these things during the Transportation Committee really got to me. It’s infuriating to report about people whose lives have been ended or forever altered by traffic collisions, to read reports from our city’s transportation experts outlining what we can do to prevent such tragedies, and then to listen to someone elected to serve our city tell those same experts that he knows the real problem is bike lanes. It’s unacceptable.

This isn’t a community council, it’s the Seattle City Council, the body tasked with spending our taxes and setting our policies. We need this body to be working together on the monumental task of reducing traffic deaths and injuries. Protected bike lanes have consistently proven to be one of the best tools we have to improve safety for all road users, including people in cars and people on foot. They calm traffic speeds and dramatically reduce the crossing distances for crosswalks, reducing to time people are exposed to car traffic collisions while also slowing the speeds of any collisions that do happen. As was outlined in SDOT’s presentation to the committee, SDOT staff is available at any time to help councilmembers get answers to any questions they have. The public’s expectation is that councilmembers will have sought out those resources before making factual claims from the dais. And if they don’t have research prepared, then they have the opportunity to ask the experts in front of them.

Despite these detours into bike lane misinformation, CM Kettle was not entirely against bike projects. He noted support for safe routes to school projects and praised the Thomas Street project, which will include protected bike lanes as well as the city’s first complete protected intersection.

So, yes, this is a harsh post about a brand new councilmember. My hope is that CM Kettle takes it as some tough advice from a longtime Council observer and reporter, because this lesson will apply to other meetings and topics as well.

About the author:

Related posts:


12 responses to “Watch: New Transportation Committee gets intro from SDOT, CM Kettle puts foot in mouth”

  1. Steve Kennedy

    Tom: Thanks for pointing out the myriad of problematic comments by CM Kettle on bike lanes. Hopefully, he will learn something from your and others feedback. His comments were really concerning coming from a Council member. Agree with you on the Magnolia Bridge— she’s not my “Queen” either.

  2. Al Dimond

    There is, of course, a problem with the Westlake Cycletrack, and it’s the same problem we have on most of our off-street bike paths: nighttime visibility is awful, especially when it’s wet out. It’s always been intended to be a major bike route and it’s in an area with a lot of other competing light sources. It needs consistent overhead lighting like any basic street would have. This path might not be the biggest focus for Vision Zero but … if we have a vision where cycling works for masses of people (which is closer to what I care about) the most popular routes have to deliver.

  3. Michael A Payne

    Thank you Tom. These roles bring a broad portfolio. We must work hard to keep our elected team focused on the data. Your analysis will make a difference. What is causing the dangerous crashes and fatalities? People driving cars who do not comply with the laws…speeding, impaired and distracted drivers.

  4. Robstra

    Thank you Tom for the thorough coverage of the Tansportation meeting and the very fair criticsm of CM Kettle. At least he didn’t try out “There is a war on cars!” :)

    1. Janine Blaeloch

      Bet he will, though.

  5. Fnarf

    If we could move the council elections to even-numbered years, we might be able to stop numbskulls like Kettle from getting elected.

    1. Ballard Biker

      Came here to say a very similar thing. Kettle (and 7/9 of our council, the mayor and attorney) is the result of low voter turnout. Not having ever missed an election since I turned 18, I can’t comprehend voters choosing not to vote, but our current voting setup makes it so a minority of voters get to choose who runs our City. Not a healthy system.

  6. Jenna Chavez, DVM

    Thank you Tom for this very well-written post. It is very important that we voice our opinions to the CM so he knows that he is wrong and does more investigating of the real danger on our streets, cars. Over 40,000 people die in the US every year from car related deaths. Please write to [email protected] and let him know how bike lanes save lives, not ruin them.

  7. RossB

    I think the Magnolia Bridge is like a queen. The Queen of England. Magnificent, but the whole concept is outdated and way too expensive. Simply not worth it. Sorry to be so harsh (too soon?).

    Kettle is the type of person who would not have been nominated in years past. He doesn’t have a good grasp of the job. An organization like the Municipal League would have given him a low rating (maybe even “unqualified”) and that would have been that. Instead the two major editorial boards (The Stranger and The Seattle Times) largely focus on policies, not competence.

  8. eddiew

    Yes, the Magnolia bridge should have a much lower priority than any other major one in Seattle (e.g., Montlake, University, Fremont, Ballard, Duwamish). Even the West Dravus Street bridge is more important; it may have an ST3 Link station next to it and will have desire lines from all modes.

  9. DOUG.

    I think not titling the post “Spotts, Meet Kettle” is a missed opportunity.

    1. Tom Fucoloro

      I regret the error.

— Advertisement —

Join the Seattle Bike Blog Supporters

As a supporter, you help power independent bike news in the Seattle area. Please consider supporting the site financially starting at $5 per month:

Latest stories

Bike Events Calendar

all-day Bicycle Weekends on Lake Washing…
Bicycle Weekends on Lake Washing…
Jun 22 – Jun 23 all-day
Bicycle Weekends on Lake Washington Blvd
Details from Seattle Parks: On scheduled weekends from May to September, a portion of Lake Washington Boulevard will be closed to motorized vehicles from 10 a.m. Saturday to 6 p.m. Sunday. “Seattle Parks and Recreation[…]
all-day Bicycle Weekends on Lake Washing…
Bicycle Weekends on Lake Washing…
Jun 23 – Jun 24 all-day
Bicycle Weekends on Lake Washington Blvd
Details from Seattle Parks: On scheduled weekends from May to September, a portion of Lake Washington Boulevard will be closed to motorized vehicles from 10 a.m. Saturday to 6 p.m. Sunday. “Seattle Parks and Recreation[…]
10:00 am NE 8th St Bridge Opening @ Totem Lake Salt & Straw
NE 8th St Bridge Opening @ Totem Lake Salt & Straw
Jun 23 @ 10:00 am – 12:00 pm
Join us for a relaxed group ride along EasTrail to the NE 8th St Bridge Opening! This is an All-Ages and Abilities event, we will not be leaving anyone behind and we will all be[…]
1:00 pm Redmond History Ride @ Marymoor Park Velodrome Parking Lot
Redmond History Ride @ Marymoor Park Velodrome Parking Lot
Jun 23 @ 1:00 pm – 4:30 pm
Redmond History Ride @ Marymoor Park Velodrome Parking Lot | Redmond | Washington | United States
Join this 13 mile bike ride around Redmond at a Leisurely pace. We’ll visit various sites both old and new as I tell stories about the city that was once known as Salmonberg.ShareMastodonTwitterFacebookRedditEmail
7:15 pm Point83 @ Westlake Park
Point83 @ Westlake Park
Jun 27 @ 7:15 pm
Point83 @ Westlake Park
Meet up in the center of the park at 7ish. Leave at 730. Every Thursday from now until forever rain or shine. Bikes, beers, illegal firepits, nachos, bottlerockets, timetraveling, lollygagging, mechanicals, good times.ShareMastodonTwitterFacebookRedditEmail
— Advertisements —

Latest on Mastodon

Loading Mastodon feed…